French auteur experimenting with a new language of cinema that uses light and the camera to attempt to involve the audience in a primal experience of the movie's events.
Plot is secondary, non-existent or indirect, the movie focusing primarily on the sensorial experience of its characters which are often involved in dark, intense, sexual,
violent or passionate life events. The camera shakes, blurs, zooms-in with extreme close-ups, delivering its darkly lit and hazy imagery in 'primal' visual experiences
that are experienced rather than seen. That's the theory, at least, and obviously, this kind of thing will not appeal to many although he made a name for himself in art-house
circles. As opposed to Zulawski, the primal emotions aren't channeled through a raw state of being and the emotions of his actors, but mostly via the camera, thus punishing
his audience that have to endure the unnatural camera and light. In addition, the topics he covers in his movies are simply not developed enough and are not interesting.
So, for the rest of us, his movies will just be a pretentious and superficial attempt to involve the audience in something unrewardingly dark by punishing their senses.
'A Lake', his third movie, is not reviewed here and covers less extreme content with similar experimental camera-work. Also released the highly experimental non-movie
'White Epilepsy' which only shows naked bodies very slowly moving and writhing in dark woods for an hour. Reviewed until 2016.
Grandrieux's sophomore experiment after Sombre is more extreme in its audio-visual primal experimentation. The movie is a patchwork of scenes, most of them
bleak, agitated, raw and dark. We see humans sold like pieces of meat, an endlessly depressing scene of a forced prostitute having her hair sliced off with
a knife, an American who falls for the whore, a disturbingly abusive client, some strange pimps and criminals, a strip-club and disco party, etc. Slowly
we piece together the cliched story of a boy who falls for a prostitute and who wants to save her from her pimps. Frantic and bestial passions are allowed
free reign, with the cinematography and sound intimately taking part in this primal fugue of life in the gutter, with even dogs being pushed to more
animalistic behaviour. But the characters are empty caricatures, the plot is non-existent, there are no insights or rewards, and the only thing this
avant-garde cinema achieves is to bring you down to its level. You can't elevate pornography to art by simply shaking the camera.
New Life, The
With a shaky, blurry, dark camera that makes Dogma '95 look like a Disney production, this film tries to explore the dark and monstrous in humanity. A
rapist-murderer who performs puppet shows for kids tours the country impulsively killing whores. When he meets a virginal beauty however, she threatens
his darkness with a loving, blinding light so he tries to rape and murder her sister and make her lose control as well. There are the beginnings of an
intense experience here (despite the fact that women are portrayed as either whores or virgins), and Grandrieux has the potential to become another Noé,
but he definitely won't get there by not letting his audience see what's happening on-screen. He also suggested the audience should edit the movie in
real-time. What's next, stare at a blank screen and imagine the whole movie ourselves?